Your Fault: London Review
Director: Charlotte Fassler and Dani Girdwood
Date Created: 2026-06-17 19:36
1.5
Your Fault: London Review: Directed by Charlotte Fassler and Dani Girdwood, the Prime Video movie stars Asha Banks and Matthew Broome as Noah and Nick, alongside Ray Fearon, Eve Macklin, Louisa Binder, Joel Nankervis, and others. Adapted from Mercedes Ron’s Culpa Tuya, the second novel in the wildly popular Culpables trilogy, the film serves as the sequel to My Fault: London.
Your Fault: London Review
When I first heard that the Culpables trilogy was getting an English-language remake, I almost said to myself, “Are we really required to have this?” Well, after watching My Fault: London, I was not satisfied, but I believed that at least it was somewhat enjoyable. It’s not very good, but okay to watch. But after watching Your Fault: London, I now wonder, why are we being forced to watch something similar each time?
Prime Video’s Your Fault: London starts with Noah and Nick attempting to keep their relationship a secret as they both enter into new stages of their life; Noah goes to study at Oxford, and Nick starts to work in his father’s business. Physical distance, jealousy, and many other things create small gaps in their relationship, which may be considered normal according to the story. However, the film takes an extremely easy path that can be predicted very easily.
Prime Video movie Your Fault: London fails to deliver in the sense that it confuses perpetual fighting with storytelling. It is clear that the majority of issues between Noah and Nick can be sorted out by a simple talk, but the movie seems to force them into constant misunderstandings just so something may happen. Rather than developing their relationship, it gets caught up in a vicious circle of mistrust and jealousy.
In time, it starts getting exhausting. The plot consistently brings up instances that try to put pressure on their relationship, yet nothing seems natural. New characters are introduced, problems keep happening, and confrontational moments are all too repetitive. Instead of creating a sense of suspense through natural means, the film makes the viewer sit and see similar conversations happen over and over again.
However, what made the first story a bit appealing was the fact that their relationship was prohibited. There was something exciting about it. In this one, though, there isn’t that kind of newness anymore. Once the initial interest wears off, there really isn’t anything much to speak of. Rather than developing an intriguing relationship, it ends up falling back on clichéd teenage romances.
This repetition hinders the characters in many ways. Noah seems to spend a lot of time reacting to events that occur instead of influencing what happens. In addition, Nick is stuck in his typical rebellious character, who seems to appear in movies again and again. The characters do not grow enough to make watching another two-hour movie worthwhile. The problem is that there were elements in the story which could have been discussed at a more profound level. In the case of the relationship between Noah and Nick, there are certain emotional and social aspects associated with this union. However, all the problems presented within the story are trivialised.
When the Your Fault: London film tries to take on an emotional turn, however, the melodrama is somewhat forced, as if the screenwriter believed that emotional intensity always results in good writing. This does not work as well as expected. Real emotions stem from the development of the characters. What must be said for the benefit of the film, Asha Banks and Matthew Broome have really tried hard to create believable chemistry. Neither of them is at fault here; actually, they happen to be the sole reason for keeping the movie interesting. While Banks manages to make Noah vulnerable enough to win hearts, Broome makes Nick attractive whenever he gets the chance to show anything but mood swings.
As expected, they succeed in doing so, which is why their chemistry is quite believable, an achievement that is quite significant considering how much the movie relies on their credibility. However, no matter how well the actors perform, their chemistry cannot compensate for the film’s inability to move forward with the storyline. Although the purpose of this film is to make people admire the riches, glamour, and romanticism, it turns out to be rather hollow despite all these elements of attractiveness. Emotional tension never seems so high, even though the creators believe the contrary, due to rather weak reasons of disagreement and misunderstandings.
To me, probably one of the main problems of this movie is that it does not justify itself at all. There was a remake of this story created by the Spaniards. It is still quite new to be considered outdated. Watching this remake, you may easily forget about the original, as there is almost nothing different in it.
Prime Video Your Fault: London Review: Summing Up
In conclusion, Your Fault: London is an attempt at extending a dying relationship to a period of two more hours, involving clichés, misunderstandings, and emotions. While there are some good performances by Asha Banks and Matthew Broome, the film cannot convince one of its existence and ends up being a remake not needed by anyone.
