Scarpetta Review
Director: David Gordon Green and Charlotte Brändström
Date Created: 2026-03-11 16:27
2
Scarpetta Review: Created by Liz Sarnoff and directed by David Gordon Green and Charlotte Brändström, the Prime Video crime drama is inspired by the popular books written by Patricia Cornwell. The eight-episode series stars Nicole Kidman as Kay Scarpetta, a forensic pathologist, along with other talented actors such as Jamie Lee Curtis, Bobby Cannavale, Simon Baker, Ariana DeBose, Rosy McEwen, and many more. Each episode is approximately 45 minutes long and revolves around the life of Kay, who is a forensic pathologist, and her investigations while facing other challenges. The series is set both in the past and the present and reveals the story behind the transformation of the investigator that she is today.
Scarpetta Review
I had hoped the Prime Video series Scarpetta would hook me with its tightly wound mystery and strong female lead. The premise is good: the best medical examiner in the country, with a passion for justice, seeks the truth in a heinous crime, while struggling with the ghosts of her past, which seem to haunt her at every turn. Sounds like the stuff of which an excellent, gripping, and emotional crime drama is made. Alas, the series sometimes seems to struggle with its own narrative, and what could be a tightly wound mystery sometimes appears messy and melodramatic.
The show centres on Kay Scarpetta, one of the most intelligent and accomplished medical examiners in the country, whose career has been built on fighting for victims of heinous crimes, those unable to defend themselves. Her latest case has connections to her past, and the show jumps around the timeline to introduce new pieces of the mystery. This can be effective in the mystery genre, with each era feeling important and relevant. But sometimes the jumps don’t feel gripping, just jarring.
At times, the mystery at the centre of the show is so convoluted and intriguing, and the crimes themselves seem eerie and atmospheric, and the use of forensic science to uncover the truth has always been intriguing, and sometimes the show manages to hit just the right tone, particularly with its focus on Scarpetta’s work.
Prime Video’s Scarpetta tends to stray away from what made us fall in love with it in the first place. Instead of focusing more on the mystery and trying to uncover more clues, it seems like a large portion of this show is more concerned with feuds and arguments between these characters. While it is important to have character development in a dramatic series, it is becoming overused in this one.
The non-linear storytelling is another issue with this series. The idea of jumping back and forth between Scarpetta’s past and present to show how it has affected her is great, but it is not executed as well as it should have been. The back and forth between timelines is causing the story to be quite slow and confusing, rather than helping it.
Also Read: One Piece Season 2 Review: Straw Hats Sail Into a Bigger, Wilder, and Visually Spectacular Adventure
Despite all the writing issues, it is quite obvious that the cast is one of the strongest features of this show. Nicole Kidman is absolutely stunning as Kay Scarpetta. Her portrayal of this woman who puts her work above everything else, including her love life, is quite intriguing. Kidman has had a long history of playing strong women in television and film, and she does it again here with this role. Although the character is not always consistently written, Kidman does keep her grounded throughout.
Young Scarpetta, played by Rosy McEwen, is really interesting as she seems to have many of the elder Scarpetta’s traits and helps bring all of the storylines together. Seeing her transition into this junior, less seasoned version of this character is an interesting spin, although it is not always utilised to its full potential.
Jamie Lee Curtis is great as Dorothy Farinelli, Scarpetta’s sister. This is another interesting thread in this series. On paper, this relationship between these two women, with their obvious contrasts and underlying tensions, has huge potential. In reality, we see them have the same few arguments over and over again, which can get dull rather than engaging.
There are also Bobby Cannavale as Pete Marino and Simon Baker as Benton Wesley, both integral to Scarpetta’s life and work. They are great in their respective roles, although this series does not really explore them beyond their obvious conflicts. Ariana DeBose plays Lucy Farinelli Watson, although this is not really given much scope.
Another aspect, which should be mentioned, is the aesthetic of Nicole Kidman’s Scarpetta. It has a dark, moody look, which works well with the content. Scenes of crime are depicted with stark realism, which can be said to be almost unsettling at times. The aesthetic and the atmosphere work well with the grim world in which the titular character has to navigate, and the quality of the cinematography makes the narrative cinematic, which makes the gaps in the narrative sting slightly more.
Prime Video Scarpetta Review: Summing Up
The Scarpetta series, in the end, appears to be a show with too many ideas competing with each other. It tries to be a psychological drama, a crime thriller, and a character study at the same time. These elements can work well together, and they will work well together with the right balance, which isn’t achieved in the show. The most engaging aspect of the show seems to be relegated to the background.
