Should I Marry a Murderer Review
Director: Josh Allott
Date Created: 2026-04-29 17:17
4
Should I Marry a Murderer Review: Under the direction of Josh Allott, this three-part true crime Netflix documentary is 50 minutes long and tells a disturbing real-life story about a forensic pathologist named Caroline Muirhead. Starting off with a stormy relationship, things take an ominous turn when her boyfriend, Sandy McKellar, confesses to having been involved in a murder case.
Should I Marry a Murderer Review
Almost beginning with the look and feel of a romance film, Netflix docuseries Should I Marry a Murderer is an intimately vulnerable story. This series narration by Caroline is essential to its mood. Unlike other documentaries that make it seem as if the subjects are only objects in a case file, this show takes the viewer into Caroline’s mind and thoughts.
Should I Marry a Murderer documentary introduces us to Caroline’s encounter with Sandy through an online dating site, their whirlwind romance, and how she decided to ignore the warning signs. The point that struck me most about this part of the film was that it didn’t make a hasty judgment on her decisions. Instead, it lets you digest the reasons behind her decisions and gives an insight into how someone who is smart and keen could fall for something like this. When Sandy finally tells Caroline about the role he played in the hit-and-run murder of Tony Parsons, it takes a completely new turn.
Here, the focus is not much on the criminal side of things but more on how much psychological pressure Caroline must have been under. Not running away, she chooses the absolutely dangerous option of cooperating with the police by collecting evidence while maintaining a relationship with Sandy. It was really interesting and quite disturbing to watch this all go down. There is always a sense of danger when you see how Caroline maintains such a pretence while risking her life.
The storytelling of Netflix’s Should I Marry a Murderer is efficient and compelling. With only three episodes in total, there is no sense of dragging. In addition, each episode adds another level of information to the story. The timing is excellent as it complements the condition of Caroline, who is calm on the outside but builds up tension from within. The personal story of the girl helps keep it realistic despite some unbelievable events.
What really lingers, however, is the psychological impact this situation has had on her. The Netflix documentary Should I Marry a Murderer does not spare us from seeing the extent to which her mental well-being has been impacted. As she stays with Sandy, even as she assists the police in their investigation, she gets scared, and she spirals into an anxiety-ridden state of mind, where she indulges in negative coping behaviours. This part of the documentary is difficult to watch, but it also carries significant weight.
However, there are certainly some weaknesses in this documentary too. For example, at times, the scenes which have been recreated seem to be somewhat off-putting. It is understandable why they have been done, since it would help viewers understand how certain events happened which couldn’t be captured. However, for me personally, scenes which have not been staged were more captivating.
A part of this story that also came across as somewhat incomplete for me was the narrow perspective from which the story was told. The narration was mostly done from the perspective of Caroline. While this makes the story all the more powerful, it may have been interesting to learn a little about the views of the investigators who took part in this story.
However, perhaps one of the most annoying parts about the film is the portrayal of the people in charge of her case. As the film goes on, it becomes apparent that Caroline did not have the security she should have had given the danger of the situation. To see her suffer through all of this while being protected by hardly anything makes you very irritated.
Netflix Should I Marry a Murderer Review: Summing Up
Ultimately, Should I Marry a Murderer docuseries succeeds due to the fact that it is not solely based on unveiling the hidden reality, but rather focuses on what this discovery costs people. It shows an individual’s emotional, psychological, and even physical toll from doing whatever he or she can in the situation that cannot be explained by any logic or common sense. On the whole, this documentary proved to be quite captivating and thought-provoking for me.
Also Read: The House of the Spirits Review: Compelling Tale That Struggles to Come Alive Fully
