Ransom Canyon Review: Aesthetic Delight, But Predictable and Flawed

Ransom Canyon Review

Director: Amanda Marsalis

Date Created: 2025-04-17 17:26

Editor's Rating:
2.5

Ransom Canyon Review: The show is directed by Amanda Marsalis and created by April Blair. It stars Minka Kelly as Quinn O’Grady, Josh Duhamel as Staten Kirkland, Lizzy Greene as Lauren Brigman, Eoin Macken as Davis Collins, James Brolin as Cap Fuller, Garrett Wareing as Lucas Russell, Jack Schumacher as Yancy Grey, Tatanka Means as Jake Longbow and many others. The series has 10 episodes, each running for about 50 minutes and is based on the book series by Jodi Thomas.

Ransom Canyon Review

Set in the picturesque Texas Hill Country, Netflix’s Ransom Canyon portrays the saga of three ranching families entangled in love, intrigue, and land feuds. It combines drama with murder mystery, depicting how people cope with pain, love, and legacy. When I first heard about this show, I was curious. As it sounds very interesting, but after finishing the whole season, I have mixed feelings.

First, the positives. The show, without a doubt, is visually stunning. The sweeping open fields, the golden sunsets, the old-fashioned houses – all of it gave the series a dreamy western vibe. It reminded me of series such as Yellowstone and Virgin River, but with Texas spin. The amazing visuals aside, I also appreciated the casting choices. The inclusion of native american characters was refreshing. It was great to see people of different backgrounds. That effort on inclusivity is something I admire.

But beautiful scenery can only carry a show so far. Once you peel away the pretty skin, Ransom Canyon series starts to unravel a bit. The biggest problem for me was the storytelling. A lot of times there just felt forced when it should have felt real, as if the writers were pushing themselves a little too hard to make the emotions come through. Every episode pushed me crazy with cliques, intense breakdowns laden with tearful looks but somehow left me feeling nothing for them. Instead, I found myself growing restless and just wanting something authentic to happen.

The main characters, especially Staten, Quinn, and Davis, didn’t really click with me. I wanted to root for them, but their personalities were hard to connect with. Staten is supposed to be the tough cowboy with a broken heart, but he often came off as cold and stiff. Quinn who owns the local dance studio and has her own history with Staten could have really shone as a strong female role and the truth is Quinn came off leaning heavily on everyone else.

And Davis? Well, he’s in this love triangle that was kind of annoying instead of really romantic. It sure seemed like they just stuck an old Western in a draw with boxy clichés and didn’t make them come alive with real depth.

The most irritating part for me was the dialogue. Some lines were overly delivered, as if actors were using a teleprompter rather than talking. There were also too many meaningless arguments, which in my opinion, detracted from the main point. People would shout and calm down, only to have the issue unresolved for the next episode. Sure, I get that the drama is part of the package, but come on, give me something to work with. The way, here it, the conflicts simply loop back to the start without moving an inch towards a solution.

Also Read: Project UFO Review: Confusing Mix of Politics, Drama, And Half-Baked Sci-Fi

Having said that, I do appreciate that the show attempts to conclude the story by the last episode. There is a minor cliffhanger, but is not the type of ending where you feel completely disoriented. I actually appreciate that, because with Netflix shows, there is no certainty whether a season two will happen. At least Ransom Canyon doesn’t leave you hanging completely.

Now, here’s what surprised me: I didn’t particularly like the characters or the storytelling, but I also didn’t dislike the experience of watching it. The slow pace has a certain charm of its own. There’s something soothing about consuming content that feels recognizable, even if it is flawed. I imagine that is the reason some people might like the show; most probably die hard fans of romantic western dramas.

But personally for me, it just didn’t stand out enough. There just wasn’t much snarl to the mystery or the squabbling of the family dynamics as I was expecting, both were a little off. When you build up a story about land, legacy, and power, you expect strong emotions and sharp twists. Instead, it felt like a marathon soap opera where mere whispers about problems never reach real solutions. And don’t get me started on the teen drama side-plots—they were just plain frustrating.

Summing Up

If you dig romance that unfolds slowly and appreciate a few classic feel-good moments, then you might like this show, but for me, I think Ransom Canyon did not work. It definitely had amazing cast, great location and a premise that had all the potential in the world. But it lacked the spark. It felt like a show trying too hard to be like Yellowstone but didn’t really know how to get there. Maybe the source material works better as a book. it just didn’t fully work for me.

Ransom Canyon 2025 is now streaming on Netflix.

Also Read: The Stolen Girl Review: Suspenseful Ride with Powerful Lead Performances That Will Keep You Hooked