Mob War: Philadelphia vs. The Mafia Review
Director: Raissa Botterman
Date Created: 2025-10-22 22:56
3
Mob War: Philadelphia vs. The Mafia Review: Directed by Raissa Botterman, this three-part Netflix docuseries dives into the bloodiest chapter of the city’s crime chronicles. Each of the episodes spans about 45 minutes, documenting the bloody turf war between the old-school Sicilian kingpin, John Stanfa, and the flashy, new-age South Philly mob boss, Joey Merlino. Initially started as a power grab for leadership of the Mafia, the war turns into an open street war, marked by gunfights, back stabbings, and FBI wiretaps, creating an actual crime epic, akin to a gangland movie. Interviews of former FBI officials, mob members, and bystanders mix with dramatic scenes and historical audio recordings.
Mob War: Philadelphia vs. The Mafia Review
There’s no disputing the real-life tale of the Mob War: Philadelphia vs. The Mafia docuseries is intriguing. When violent Philadelphia mob boss Nicky Scarfo was put behind bars later in the ’80s, it opened up a dangerous power vacuum. Two factions appeared to stake their claim, each aligned with Scarfo’s old guard under John Stanfa and the new wave under the young and ambitious Joey Merlino. Their struggle for power immediately descended into madness. Shots were exchanged in open streetways and even on highways, and corpses began to accumulate.
The docuseries does an excellent job chronicling how all of this went down. It doesn’t mess around, foreshadowing the most shocking punches and arrests through the sporadic use of archive footage and testimony. You can appreciate how much effort went into keeping the chronology easy to follow by director Raissa Botterman and staff. For those new to Philly organised crime lore, the docuseries makes the perfect primer.
Netflix’s Mob War: Philadelphia vs. The Mafia edits are tightly done. Cuts are concise, the rhythm doesn’t lag too far behind, and the combination of talking-head interviews and reconstruction seems just right. The docuseries also gets excellent access to individuals genuinely of the mob existence, all the way from hitman-informant John Veasey through mob boss mistress Ruthann Seccio to even chefs who once catered to South Philly mobsters. Listening to them reminisce, frequently by using dark humour, gives the program the ring of truth.
Another massive highlight of the documentary is the actual use of real FBI wiretap recordings. Those are the scenes giving us a raw, creepy atmosphere to the screen; hearing gangsters discuss crime in their own voices makes for a different impact. We don’t have many of those scenes, though. I wished the series had utilised those tapes instead of the latter run-of-the-mill talking heads of individuals recapping what happened. Netflix has attempted this kind of programming once previously, though, as they did with the Conversations with a Killer series, where actual audio firsthand makes all the difference. This too had the same power, but didn’t utilise it sufficiently.
While the real story is dramatic, Mob War: Philadelphia vs. The Mafia documentary does not succeed in making it seem so dramatic as it does every now and then. It looks nice, pretty visuals, and the interviews are interesting, but sooner or later, it just feels like the tried-but-true pattern of so many of the other true-crime docuseries on Netflix. Everything is so slick, so by-the-book: crime, interview, reenactment, and round and round.
Tone is yet another problematic area. Certain parts ring uproariously, though unintentionally, once certain mobmen go on far-fetched laments right out of comedy routines. At one time, a hitman lectures on setting his own hand on fire, trying to get rid of evidence. It’s absurd, and while showing just how messy and unruly the real mob life was, the editing does not appear certain how seriously or darkly comedic this should be handled.
Also Read: Lazarus Review: Confusing Harlan Coben Thriller That Promises Depth but Delivers Disappointment
It also doesn’t delve so much into the emotional or human aspects of these men. Why would someone like Merlino crave crime fame? Why would someone like the industrious soldier Veasey betray his patron? These are questions the docuseries raises but doesn’t delve much further into. That makes the docuseries seem like a long-form timeline and not so much of an emotional narrative.
Visuals are slick. Re-enactments are fashionable and are undoubtedly the result of the great gangster films of the quality of Goodfellas or Casino. You get the feel of the time — the flashy suits, smoke-filled rooms, and the greed and loyalty of the mob. Occasionally, though, the program does style but not substance. Drama and crime are well re-created, but not given an emotional hook where you would actually become invested in the individuals.
Mob War Philadelphia vs The Mafia Review: Summing Up
Overall, Netflix docuseries Mob War: Philadelphia vs. The Mafia comes in the middle. It isn’t by any means a poor production, but it doesn’t quite bring much. It is interesting because of what the actual story is, but the presentation comes off as too conservative and far too much like any of the other true-crime presentations offered by Netflix. But if you are someone who would be intrigued by stories of mobsters, FBI investigations, and the corrupting power of politics, it makes for an entertaining and convenient viewing. You get the perfect amount of blood, betrayal, and courtroom vengeance to keep you through the three episodes.
